Internet not acting as speed tests suggest it should

  • 2
  • Question
  • Updated 1 day ago
  • Acknowledged
Alright, so I am just wondering if anyone else has experienced this before, when you test your streaming speed on Fast.com and it consistently says your streaming speed is far above what is needed to stream in your selected quality, yet it still struggles to actually stream the video.  

For example, from time to time I will get 3-4mbps results on fast.com, they will stay consistent like that for at least an hour or two, but I still try to stream in 480p, the viewing quality that the silver plan permits.  Yet, it still struggles to load the video on YouTube.  This baffles me, because as the speed test says I should be able to load 720p without issue, yet it is struggling to load 480p.  

I understand a lot of you recommend using auto on YouTube and other such websites, but I dislike auto 240p.  So, I manually set it to 480p, which should *not* be an issue as when I have priority data (which I do) in theory I should be able to stream 480p. On testmy.net I seldom ever get below 10mbps, in fact I usually get above that speed, which is nice for when I wish to download something, but since I primarily stream and this plan has a limited streaming speed does not help me with that. 

You may be wondering why i brought it up then, well it was to show that my "normal" speed is significantly above 1.5mbps, yet even with nobody else home and my computer being the sole device connected, I may not always get 1.5mbps on fast.com while still getting those good speeds on testmy.net.  

This has been something that doesn't happen everyday, but it does happen often enough that I wonder what the deal is.  So, that's why I marked this as a question rather than a problem I am having, I am curious to hear if anyone else has had similar problems with the Bronze, Silver and Gold plans.  


















(By the way Stephen, I too, have a Playon server, it works quite well, except it does often record Netflix shows in lower quality than I'd like, but thus far it downloads Hulu shows in good quality.  For the record, I have it set to record in "auto" quality and download only at a family member's house who has cable internet, so if you have any tips on getting guaranteed HD Netflix recordings, that'd be appreciated.)
Photo of Marika

Marika

  • 96 Posts
  • 51 Reply Likes

Posted 6 days ago

  • 2
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
I too have this problem more often than not. ViaSat' s video data extender does not get along well with YouTube or Netflix. Netflix especially. It can be very very frustrating trying to watch 240p Netflix on a 42 inch television. I have reported this problem many times with no help. Too bad we can't shut off our video data extender like most other plans allow.
Photo of L.L.

L.L.

  • 22 Posts
  • 8 Reply Likes
So many other factors may be coming into play here.
- Netflix is never going to play nice with any of this
- Device used
- Net Nuetrality too, although no one would ever admit to it.

So often subscribers experience poor performance from their “smart TV’s” and think it’s the ISP causing the issue especially after a speed test shows favorable results. Smart TVs use terrible processors in them and almost never go without buffering. I’ve seen 500 Mbps cable wirelessly connected to a smart TV and YouTube, Netflix and Hulu all buffering.

Try hardwiring your TV or laptop directly to your modem too.
Photo of Andy Schack

Andy Schack, Champion

  • 319 Posts
  • 190 Reply Likes
I also have noticed a vast difference in video quality after Viasat employed their video ext technology. I'm not sure exactly how all of that stuff works technically but there is a difference between Viasat setting a quality level and me setting it on my Roku device. 

In the past I got into my Roku's video streaming quality and had it set where I used about 1/3 gig/hr and on my 70" 4K TV the picture was very acceptable....was  pretty much dvd quality. After they did the auto 480p, the quality stayed pretty much the same. Then our VS1 beam started getting very crowded when they began offering the 150g plan again a few months ago and I started noticing a lowering of the video quality.....some nights MUCH lower....virtually unwatchable. 

Now that I've also got a VS2 Bronze Plan system here at the house as well I've been able to test it to see how it fares. In my opinion, the video quality is not even close to what I experienced back in the days when there was no Viasat video quality presets. It's watchable but definitely NOT dvd quality. Now mind you, I am using the EXACT same amount of data as before. The difference is that NOW the video quality/stream rate is being set by Viasat where in the past it was being controlled by my Roku device. 

I guess the moral to the story is that not all video quality controlling technology is created equal. 

BTW, in case you are wondering what I am talking about when I mention the ability to adjust your Roku's stream setting......you press HOME 5 times, REWIND 3 times, and FAST-FORWARD 2 times and there you are. 

Andy
Photo of VeteranSatUser

VeteranSatUser, Champion

  • 2149 Posts
  • 1136 Reply Likes
Lost in Space. Okay series, but hard to beat the original. But for a Netflix series, it is a cinema quality production. Netflix basically blows away network television series in terms of quality and production.

I have a Roku but haven't played around with it. Will have to test. Really need something to watch Amazon content because of course my Viasat speed during primetime is too slow to stream anything real time.
Photo of Andy Schack

Andy Schack, Champion

  • 319 Posts
  • 190 Reply Likes
Jim, glad to hear it worked for you. About 3 yrs ago I actually suggested that they, Viasat, work out some kind of deal with Roku where we could give a new customer a basic Roku device. Roku's technology is simply the best out there AND it works with any of the streaming services. 
Another thing that can make a big difference is having a 4K tv.....let me correct myself, a GOOD 4K tv. The scalers in the 4k's really make a difference in the pic quality, no matter what the video source is. I've got Dish's Hopper 3 and when I switched from our regular led tv to a 4k, the pic quality difference was astounding. To me, regular led tvs look a little blurred now that I'm used to seeing mine.

For the record, I set mine at the second from the bottom (the Roku setting) .6 and then tried the .3 and there was absolutely NO difference in data usage. Don't know why but that's what I found.

Andy
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1759 Posts
  • 1410 Reply Likes
Now the big question. Can doing this stop a lot of buffering people with very slow speeds are having? Vetsat, can you try your Roku and see if you can stream at your slow speeds?
Photo of VeteranSatUser

VeteranSatUser, Champion

  • 2149 Posts
  • 1136 Reply Likes
Yea. I will try to play around with it. By primetime I should have speeds of 500k. I can try with Amazon through Roku and then the Blu Ray or Smartv
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1759 Posts
  • 1410 Reply Likes
So if you set the Roku to .3 then your 500k should be enough to keep things happy.  Real world may be different!
Photo of Bev

Bev, Champion

  • 2805 Posts
  • 1130 Reply Likes
I agree, I'm supposed to have 480 res. well, mostly I get 240 except when it glitches and forgets me and I get 720 or 1080.

I don't like the forced video throttling, be okay if it worked as intended but, it doesn't most of the time. Plan A watch only on cell phone, Plan B pray for the "forgot me" glitch. Plan C hope Viasat gets it fine tuned and working properly soon.
Photo of Brad

Brad, Viasat Employee

  • 2814 Posts
  • 918 Reply Likes
You should be able to toggle the data extender on/off I wonder if that helps in these situations. You don't really need a lot of speed to stream (hence why some DSL plans offer 4mbps and call it good) I know some factors like the device like VeteranSatUser suggested might be a culprit too. 

This might be worth a call to our tier 2/tier 3 tech support team
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1758 Posts
  • 1408 Reply Likes

"Toggle on/off if you're on a Liberty Plan*"

Or if you're on the Freedom Plan*****

Photo of Bev

Bev, Champion

  • 2795 Posts
  • 1127 Reply Likes
Nope, Unlimited Silver, can't turn it off. I don't mind 480, don't stream on large screen TV but, 240 is ridiculous outside of peak hours.
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1758 Posts
  • 1408 Reply Likes

I think we have done enough samples on streaming speeds on the "unlimited" plans to  see that Viasat is on the very low end of what is considered 480p.

Netflix:

1 Mb/s for viewing standard definition on a laptop computer. While you can stream Netflix at speeds of 1 Mb/s, the quality will be grainy on a large screen, much like watching an old VHS movie

  • 2 Mb/s for viewing standard definition video (480p) on a TV
  • 4 Mb/s for viewing high-def video (720p, 1080p)
(Edited)
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Last night I noticed another family member was streaming Netflix and the picture was not getting any better. So I clicked the special menu button to see the bitrate/resolution and these were the results. It was during primetime so I shut off everything pulling data and ran a speed test. It came back to my surprise at around 13mbps. So this just really makes no sense to me. It's so frustrating.
Photo of VeteranSatUser

VeteranSatUser, Champion

  • 2139 Posts
  • 1131 Reply Likes
That video speed is bad!

Something is off somewhere.
(Edited)
Photo of MEM

MEM

  • 28 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
I have the same problem also. There are times when the speed test indicates web pages should load reasonably fast. However the web pages load at dial-up speeds. I never have a need to stream and am quite content with sending/receiving emails and web surfing.

A cynic could speculate that Viasat intentionally puts gaps in the download speed so that a speed curve is shaped like a saw-tooth or sine wave. This might give the impression that download speeds are faster than they actually are. Consider a voltmeter that measures your household voltage to be 110 volts AC. That is the macroscopic result. When examined microscopically in increments of 1/60 th of a second, the voltage is constantly changing from +110 volts to zero volts to -110 volts and back to zero volts in a sinusoidal shape.

If this were the case then the user would be misdirected into thinking the problem is with his equipment rather than with the actual integrated speed coming from Viasat.

Confusing? Yes. Intentional? Don't know.
Photo of Stephen Rice

Stephen Rice

  • 1779 Posts
  • 782 Reply Likes
Sounds like a good conspiracy.  I've got my tin foil hat ready.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
11:32am Sunday. Can't watch tv without it buffering. I shut everything pulling data off (except my phone) ran a speed test and here's the results:

P.s. @Stephen Rice - no need to reply to this comment of mine. I already know your service is spectacular. Plus you'd just tell me something I already know.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Okay man. Can we get back to helping eachother out with these video stream throttle problems? If you don't have any Interest in helping then stop commenting please. It's not funny.
Photo of Stephen Rice

Stephen Rice

  • 1763 Posts
  • 777 Reply Likes
That's because you are to nice to me. I like it rough.
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1758 Posts
  • 1407 Reply Likes
Ethan, you say you stream on 2 Rokus at once on occasion?  You have that good of speed at certain times?
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Sometimes yes. Not very often though. Pretty easy to stream two rokus with Netflix simultaneously due to the fact that they are both streaming 240 resolution. :(
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1758 Posts
  • 1407 Reply Likes

Have you tried Andy's trick with the Bit rate on the Roku?

( we need to start a Roku thread and test some of this stuff out)

Photo of Bev

Bev, Champion

  • 2805 Posts
  • 1130 Reply Likes
Ethan, a couple of points. First on the SB2+ modem (the Viasat 1 wifi modem) wifi speeds are typically slower than wired, as my post further up in this thread shows. Second, Download speed should be between 4-5 Mbps except rarely during heavy congestion on your beam.

Video on Unlimited Silver will ALWAY be at 1-1.5 Mbps, that means 480 resolution or lower, as the Fast.com speed test shows. Now on a widescreen it's going to buffer a bit at even 480, for larger screen, to watch without buffering, you may need to force it to an even lower resolution and, during high usage times on your beam, you'll want to go with 240 if you don't want a bit of buffering.

Anything above 480 is going to buffer every time PERIOD, the higher the resolution, the worse the buffering. Our video is at 1 Mbps, that's it, that's all we get for video, work on that assumption and, you'll know what to expect.
Photo of Stephen Rice

Stephen Rice

  • 1779 Posts
  • 782 Reply Likes
I tried to say they wouldn't get HD with 1 mbps but they just told me to quit kissing Viasat's butt.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Oh yeah man. You're just so funny and witty. Just stop. You're not amusing anyone but yourself and that's really sad. Everyone else including myself is on here to talk about issues with our internet...and to help eachother problem solve. You're acting like a damn child. So do us a favor and stop. You like this so much.....make your own "stephen loves ViaSat" forum.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
And also I forgot to mention. I used a vpn for a while with ViaSat and tested my bitrate and it was upwards of 5mbps at 1080p. So I know that something is screwy with the video data extender.
Photo of Jim16

Jim16, Champion

  • 1758 Posts
  • 1407 Reply Likes
I have seen you post that star button thing before.  I have tried that and it does not show my speed on the screen like yours.  I have the Roku Ultra.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
It only works on Netflix.
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
While it's playing that is...
Photo of Bev

Bev, Champion

  • 2792 Posts
  • 1125 Reply Likes
Step Son just returned his recently purchased Roku Express. YouTube and Netflix are fine for him, no buffering, running at 360 day and 240 Prime time. (He's on the Bronze plan.) Roku, even at the lowest setting buffered every 2-3 minutes.

I helped him troubleshoot it and, it didn't take long for me to figure out that it was either the Roku Express or Roku's server, not his internet.

If other streams like Netflix and You Tube are fine, then it's the provider or the device, not the internet.
Photo of Brad

Brad, Viasat Employee

  • 2814 Posts
  • 918 Reply Likes
This thread is starting to get heated. Please refrain from personal attacks and name calling as it's a violation of our forum guidelines. 

This is a open community for ALL Viasat customers. While support and help is the primary focus, keep in mind that not all users are upset with the product and are legitimately trying to help fellow customers. They are in no way compensated by Viasat. Likewise we don't want a customer that's upset to feel attacked by people that like the service.  If you'd rather speak to Viasat directly and not engage in spats on here please email viasatlistens@viasat.com to speak directly with the Corporate Social Care team.
Photo of MEM

MEM

  • 27 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
So Brad, Viasat Employee,

Why does my post a few days ago state:

"This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies."

This gag order was imposed after only one day of its initial post.

There is no profanity.
There is no name calling.
There are no personal attacks.
There is no overheating.

See my post titled "Comments from a Long Time User" by MEM.
Who could have added this restriction and why?
Photo of Ethan Farrell

Ethan Farrell

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Brad, I am sorry things got heated. There's a certain user on here who gets mouthy and disrespectful and thinks its funny and I'd had enough. I like this forum. It's great for problem solving. Thank you.
Photo of Brad

Brad, Viasat Employee

  • 2814 Posts
  • 918 Reply Likes
No worries Ethan. That was directed at multiple users obviously. I think somewhere buried under all the unnecessary bickering some good advice and suggestions came up over streaming settings that might be useful. 
Photo of Oliver

Oliver

  • 84 Posts
  • 23 Reply Likes
I also see this problem with the video data extender. I have two viasat 1 systems. One of my accounts allows me to turn it off so it's easy for me to test and compare. Viasat's video data extender glitch's out many times and I can't even stream 480p or it will give me 1080p in 1 out of 10 videos.