Archived and Closed
This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies and is no longer visible to community members.
I am a network trace engineer for Microsoft for the last 9 years and have been working in the network industry for the last 24 years. I recently moved into a lake house and ordered Exede Service. After the technician hooked up the satellite, I logged in to set up my account and it showed 2.1GB of usage after 10 minutes (and the only thing I was doing was setting up my account) because of that I connected my network sniffer behind my router to get a 100% accurate byte count. It ran all night and the sniffer hardware showed 900mb of data over night. When I logged on to my Exede account it showed 9.1GB.
It's obvious there is a problem. It is either with the way they collect the data or how they calculate, but they need to focus on the problem and fix it. It is obvious I'm not receiving the service I am paying for. I would like an answer from Exede and lacking that, I would say this is prime for a class action suit. If I can hook up a network sniffer, so can others and I would say that if this has been going on for months or years across all Exede customers, this could be millions of dollars they are bilking us out of.
- 5 Posts
- 3 Reply Likes
Posted 5 years ago
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
Thanks,
Jack
- 2 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 4 Posts
- 0 Reply Likes
- 171 Posts
- 19 Reply Likes
I was thinking of switching over from hughes net to here but seems it is the same problems with a different name. didn't they boast that speeds with exede were higher than the plans showed usually? what happened there? lol
- 957 Posts
- 536 Reply Likes
- 35 Posts
- 22 Reply Likes
I just did a quick check here.
Brian, Champion
- 296 Posts
- 216 Reply Likes
I've been using Exede for almost 18 months and have not had a problem with data consumption although it is clear that many have.
Thank you for doing actual network forensics. I've contemplated a network sniffer but haven't had the time or inclination to operationalize it.
Please keep us informed as this unfolds.
- 81 Posts
- 45 Reply Likes
I wonder if that contract we signed to get Exede service waived our right to take them to court and restricted grievances to arbitration? The problem with all of the class action suits I have seen is that the typical settlement results in small, very small, payouts to members of the class, and a multi-million dollar payout to the attorneys. Still, from Exede's point of view a class action would be financially painful and really hurt their ability to recruit and retain customers.
So come on, Exede. There's a problem with your data measurement system. It's broke. Fix it!
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 848 Posts
- 244 Reply Likes
Just to be clear for my own curiosity, did you place the sniffer between your router / firewall and the Exede modem or did you place it between your router / firewall and the rest of your client systemst? I am just curious as it would be interesting to see what the byte counts from both sides of that look like. From your post I would conclude it was between your network and the firewall / router. Of course it could be that you don't have a router in place and are just plugged directly into the Exede modem in which case I totally misread the post.
What sniffer are you using? I have placed a makeshift system in place running Wireshark with two bridged NICs in it as a poor man's sniffer before. It might be fun to set two of these up - 1 before the router / fireall and 1 after it to compare the traffic. I often wonder if there might be a difference in packet / byte counts due to some sort of settings on the Exede network.
Please keep us up to date with your findings as I am very interested to see the conclusions.
- 5 Posts
- 3 Reply Likes
Sorry, Just getting back to this. I sniffed the outbound side of the router so I could capture all traffic coming through the router and hitting the sat modem. I used WireShark also. It's really overkill to just measure volume but I had it loaded up so that's what I used.
Just an FYI for everyone on the thread. If you happen to be using a NetGear Router, the firmware on the router includes a traffic meter. Since I don't intend to dedicate a machine all month long to watch the traffic (but I do want to make sure Exede is counting accurately), I have done a couple of things:
1.) Connected a single machine to the router and only allowed that single MAC address to connect. Along with WPA encryption, this will make sure no one is hacked into the router (well.. as sure as you can be nowadays... but really... no one is going to drive 30 miles in the country to hack my router..)
2.) Enabled the Traffic Meter on the router
3.) On the Windows 8.1 machine connected to the router, I zeroed the byte count on the network connection and enabled it to show data usage when I open the network connection.
For all intents and purposes this will show me a fairly accurate approximation of what I'm seeing going into the router and coming out of the router to the Exede Modem. I would expect to see a 2% to 5% difference in what I'm seeing on the computer and router because the data usage on the computer doesn't count local broadcast traffic, etc. BUT.. if I see a large discrepancy between what I'm seeing on the local computer and the router vs the Exede modem, I will connect the sniffer back up and expect to go deep with the Network analysts at Exede. I can send them traces and they can compare to what they say I'm doing (but I'm not going to pay to upload the huge trace file that will get generated... just saying...)
- 37 Posts
- 12 Reply Likes
I found another helpful fix for not allowing Windows updates also. Search for this file "add_gpedit_msc_by_jwils896-d3kh6vm". This uses the GPEDIT.MSC command to administratively Set Windows to NOT start any update downloads before Midnight Have to set that time)
Type in gpedit.msc in search of run window.
Click on first Administrative Template
Click on Windows Components
Click on windows Update
Click on configure automatic updates
In window that opens, Mark Enable
Below set time to 00:00
I also checked Install during automatic maintainance
At bottom of window hit Apply and OK.
Worked perfectly last night. Checked eSVT and all downloads were after Midnight.
So far, So good!!
This command is already in Pro and above versions and the above file makes it work on the lower versions of win 7, 8, 8.1, 10 Tech Preview.
Brian, Champion
- 296 Posts
- 216 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
For those unfamiliar with how to determine their beam and gateway, the beam map at:
http://www.northlc.com/_images/beam_priority_map.png
can be used to determine beam/gateway pairing (fairly easy to determine provided your not near overlappping beam areas) .
Determining core node (or Accelenet server) requires doing a tracert and generally the 5th or 6th hop in the tracert represents your core node. It used to be a little easier since that hop was generally the one with an easily recognized city in the name. With changes however, it helps to know airport codes (or so it appears).
Executing tracert google.com I get
slc-edge-11.inet.qwest.net [72.164.196.113]
for the 6th hop with slc representing the Salt Lake City core node.
P.S. Those of us who subscribe through NRTC have an easier way to determine our beam and gateway - it's right there on our account pages - ViaSat would do well to do the same.
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
Obviously, it can't be solved here but you might be able to get efforts focused on the right haystack if not the needle and a differential diagnosis may help.
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
I called just a few minutes ago and was told " oh we will probably have to send someone out to look at the modem. They will call you to set up a appointment in 24-48 hours."
I had to speak to atleast 5 different people, one phone service rep was rude and told me its my fault that I have a Virus, I assured her I ran several scans and nothing showed up, then she told me I was wrong.
Generally I have great service with Wildblue/exede, have used them almost 10 years. This is the first time I am now seriously considering going to their competitor. The level of customer service has dropped way down, and I feel like I am getting ripped off on the Data usage.
- 81 Posts
- 45 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
Core node I get #6slc-edge-11.inet.qwest.net [72.164.196.113]
#7dvr-edge-13.inet.qwest.net [67.14.24.93]
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
However it does appear Sonya is in an area (beam 325) where the new Essential and Liberty Plans are being offered which may be relevant assuming her spike coincides with the new plan roll-outs. With their introduction, I envision that the usage tracking algorithm has some increased complexity now and more room for error. But again just guessing...
- 81 Posts
- 45 Reply Likes
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
Steve Frederick-VS1/Beam314, Champion
- 3176 Posts
- 2042 Reply Likes
- 1 Post
- 1 Reply Like
- 1827 Posts
- 163 Reply Likes
- 2 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 81 Posts
- 45 Reply Likes
The installer is a contractor who does the grunt work of installing and setting up your hardware. The matter of the 2-year contract is plainly spelled out on the Exede website and in the paper contract you signed when the installer brought it to you. You do read contracts before signing them, don't you?
Even at the $50 monthly level, you're looking at a $1200 commitment plus equipment rental or lease of another$240. However, if you are not able to resolve your data leakage problem and decide to cancel early you will pay an early termination fee that is much less than that $1440 total.
- 317 Posts
- 76 Reply Likes
- 1827 Posts
- 163 Reply Likes
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
Last night when I went to bed I was at 600 mb. At midnight I started updates and downloads on the midnight to 5 "free zone" this morning when I got up my data usage shows I am at 1.6 GB USED ALREADY after just the first day of the new period. Obviously, the data I used during the "free zone" is being counted against my data usage.
Can you please correct this? I don't want to be throttled again this month, after only a couple weeks. I am watching the data, used by my calculations and your calculations as well and there is substantial discrepancy there as well, but these are your counts.
This continuing unresolved issue is very frustrating!
Thank you for your attention in this matter.
- 1827 Posts
- 163 Reply Likes
Brian, Champion
- 296 Posts
- 216 Reply Likes
Blame it auto-correct with a sense of humor.
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 2 Posts
- 0 Reply Likes
I had some data leakage while with Exede Residential, which I had for 14 months. Data leakage seemed to run about 50MB per day, so it resulted in a manageable 1 to 2 GB per month (I had the 25GB plan). However, during February and March of 2015, data leakage went up and I soon found I was "exceeding" the Exede 25 GB plan. Exede said that by switching to Exede Business, with a dedicated IP, I should see much improved data management. Therefore I bit the bullet, paid another $299, and moved to the Exede Business 30GB plan.
OOOPS. I switched on April 12, and by April 15, 20 GB of data had been consumed. We don't stream video or music (other than the occasional YouTube), and this data consumption was 5 times my consumption from the previous month while on Exede Residential (I we had not changed any of our behaviors or connected equipment). We are not "cloud bound", don't game online, and sync everything through direct connection. We generally do not command a lot of data. However, when I contacted Exede (on numerous occasions), they continually tried to figure out what I was doing wrong!
In the meantime, another 10 GB of data disappeared in a matter of days.
Well, my continuing efforts to figure this out have been in vane. Exede has now recorded more than 40 GB of data usage in the past 16 days, and I have been forced to purchase 10GB of extra data to keep marginal connectivity. My data meter shows that the modem keeps an "open" data connection to the static IP address that eats between 1 and 2 KB/sec with no actual connected device activity. We have disconnected everything from the modem and are using a cellular hotspot to survive and stay reasonably connected. I had to buy a GB of data today to get the new modem tested. I just checked and in about 30 minutes, a quarter of the data was lost.
I can only hope that Exede wakes up - there is a constant data loss in the system, probably to keep satcom, and with the static IP on the business account, the satcom packet requirements seem to be astronomical.
- 2 Posts
- 0 Reply Likes
When talking with Exede they said they could not monitor current usage, but had to look back to the previous 24 hours. However, the "usage" page clearly monitors real time usage, since it cuts me off pretty quickly when my current extra GB purchase is consumed.
By the way, I meant "in vain" above.
- 1 Post
- 3 Reply Likes
I am now going to more closely monitor, because this has become such a bad user experience that Exede must be corrected, and since they are not doing it on there own it is up to their customers. On that note I will not be using Exede after my contract is up, I would rather have a working dial-up connection then a internet that gets turned off constantly.
- 37 Posts
- 12 Reply Likes
Any time a packet is "Lost" the Internet protocol demands a retransmission until it gets the right information. A tree limb or even a small twig in the sight path can cause havoc. Visually check the line of sight, loose hardware, loose connections, corroded connections, etc.
Again, Packet loss is NOT a viable answer without further examination on all parties ends. Exede and the customer.
- 9 Posts
- 2 Reply Likes
That said, my experience with Exede CS points to either ignorance, incompetence or outright prevarication. There is no point in raising an issue, no point in contacting CS, and just today I had a CSR feign ignorance that escalation was even a possibility for a technical issue I'm having.
- 2 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
Very frustrating........
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
- 52 Posts
- 38 Reply Likes
Thanks,
Jack
- 1 Post
- 1 Reply Like
david, Champion
- 562 Posts
- 399 Reply Likes
This said, Exede does have problems occasionally and they're not forthcoming about it. In a little over two years we have been hit twice with a data loss that wasn't our fault, once when the LNFZ didn't start until about 2am and once when almost 4 gigs just disappeared within 15 minutes but except for that we use about what Exede says.
- 987 Posts
- 718 Reply Likes
- 269 Posts
- 156 Reply Likes
- 70 Posts
- 21 Reply Likes
Sorry Jep there is a real problem.
- 35 Posts
- 22 Reply Likes
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
Brian, Champion
- 296 Posts
- 216 Reply Likes
- VOD only at night. I've implemented a way so I don't have to stay up until midnight to kick off a recording.
- Neither Smart Phone in the house is allowed to autonomously connect to the router.
- Whenever I walk away from the laptop (and even when I'm using it but don't have any need for the Internet) I turn the wireless laptop radio off.
That said, early in this billing cycle, I inadvertently left the laptop wireless radio on (connected to the Internet) for more almost two days. I was horrified to find I had used almost 5 GB. I was certain that I had a data leak.
So, over the last weekend I ran a test. Friday afternoon, when I unplugged the router from the satellite modem, I had used 7.3 GB. I left the router disconnected until about 10PM Sunday. Over the weekend I checked usage several times (not from home). The usage meter didn't change.
Sunday, when I returned home, the usage meter was still at 7.3GB.
My conclusions:
- Leaving my laptop connected to the Internet for almost two days used a ton of bandwidth,
- I do not have a data leakage problem.
- Others could have different experiences.
Of course, you'll have to check your data usage from a coffee shop or library or Smart Phone.
- 94 Posts
- 33 Reply Likes
- 40 Posts
- 8 Reply Likes

- 37 Posts
- 12 Reply Likes
- 3 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
Back to the data usage issue...I have been checking our account and never have noticed any data being used when we were not at the cabin. Now we don't have a router on it and I never leave the computer plugged in when we are not using it. I'm wondering if any of these data issues are from people that 1. have routers. 2. leave their PCs plugged in and on. 3. have routers and many wireless devices that connect to it (like PC, phone, Xbox, etc.).
Ours is about the most basic system one could use...Exede dish into the ViaSat modem, cable into the PC or Amazon Fire TV box (so essentially only using one device at a time. The only time we've gone over our 10 GB is when we've streamed like crazy over Christmas at the cabin. Anyway, just my 2 cents worth and observation.
- 3 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 81 Posts
- 45 Reply Likes
- 3 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 26 Posts
- 12 Reply Likes
- 2 Posts
- 1 Reply Like
- 40 Posts
- 8 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
Getting a handle on your data usage is a daunting task at best. Hopefully an Exede moderator will weigh in on your post and request that you send your account information to them via email. They'll be able to provide you with a categorized, general breakdown of your usage and determine whether there is a "mechanical" problem with your modem or service.
Barring that, most don't find the categorized breakdown of usage too helpful in getting a handle on their usage but it's a start.
Some data usage tips can be found here:
https://community.exede.com/exede/topics/data-usage-tips
However, with satellite internet anbd capped data plans you'll find it necessary to constantly keep an eye on your usage (web site developers come up with new ways to burn through your data on nearly a daily basis).
The easiest way to do that is with your router if it has sufficient traffic monitoring facilities. If not, you'll find investment in a new router that does have that is well worth the cost. My current recommendation for router is the ASUS RT-N66U - but others have their own preferences.
- 40 Posts
- 8 Reply Likes
- 4281 Posts
- 4367 Reply Likes
If a problem occurs with usage for the wrong reason it's best to have them on when it occurs and contact support and get it escalated (and hope you receive a proper credit) if you in fact want the problem fixed - you can't diagnose spit if everything is turned off Avoiding a problem and getting it fixed are two separate things.
Leave it on, take one for the community and help get it fixed... or not.
In Exede's case, data is reported at regular intervals, unplug your modem, comeback later and plug it in and all data that hadn't been reported prior to unplugging and after the last usage check will show up - whether a significant amount depends on what you were doing prior to unplugging. The usage meter is always a glimpse at that past.
Regardless of whose problem it is, knowing what your usage is will help make a more reasoned argument with ViaSat - a quality router with adequate traffic monitoring is your friend in that regard and is a small price to pay for sanity.
- 542 Posts
- 279 Reply Likes
1 hr./day web browsing = 1.8 GB/month
10 emails/day = 0.003 GB/month
2 hrs./ week social media = 0.514 GB/month
15 photos/week = 0.193 GB/month
20 file downloads/week = 0.257 GB/month
1 hr./day streaming music = 1.2 GB
15 min./week video chat = 0.103 GB
2 hrs./month std def movies = 1.5 GB
2 hrs./month hi def movies = 4.6 GB
My first suspicion would be your DirecTV. Be sure you do not keep it connected to your modem except for when you specifically need it. As you can see above, a couple of HD movies alone will suck up most of your monthly data. Satellite internet is not for people who want to do much video.
- 37 Posts
- 12 Reply Likes
Have 4 routers of varying degrees of sophistication and finally settled on a Netgear WNDR 3700 V4. It has the ability in Advanced Settings to set Access Control.
Sellected the Hopper and Joey, and set them to not allow internet access from 0500 to 2400. Also did the same with My HP Printer which has internet print capabilities. Have been watching Modem activity, and Router Traffic meter.
So far lookin' good.
- 380 Posts
- 74 Reply Likes
This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies.
This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies.
Kim s
Exede Beau
Kim s